Director: Ed Harris
Writer: Robert Knott and Ed Harris; Robert B. Parker (Novel)
2008
I was going to give this film a rating of one, but then I remembered I gave Righteous Kill a one, and Appaloosa is not as terrible as that “film”. If you know Ed Harris directed this film then it all makes sense – he puts himself in the main role, he is always onscreen, and everyone and everything revolves around him. I know this film is based on a novel in the western genre, but I will never ever concede my opinion that this film is not in any way, what I would call a western. Set up the time period of the old west, put in some ubiquitous frontier shots of dry deserts, horses, sunsets and you’ve got yourself a western, right? Wrong. There is more to a western than commonplace costumes, locations and characters (ie, the good cowboy, the bad guy trying to run the town, the woman around town everyone know – if you know what I mean). Not for one second did I believe Jeremy Irons was the western archetypal bad guy. He was more of a corporate bad guy, trying to run the town from far away, he did not engage in enough fights, and all he wanted was to buy the town and make it better. If that’s not wimpy I don’t know what is. Where was the violence? And the struggle of good versus evil? Drag a man by a horse, kill an entire family (a la Once Upon a Time in the West – now that Fonda was a bad guy!), ride through the town with your band of baddies pillaging, shoot it out in the streets, wreak havoc and make the town a worse version of Pottersville! What Appaloosa had was Ed Harris trying to woo Renée Zellweger whilst getting irritated that Jeremy Irons descends his hilltop fortress from time to time to cause a wee bit of trouble in the town. The small saving grace (but not saving enough) was Viggo Mortensen’s quiet, subdued character and had the relationship between he and Ed Harris’ character been developed more it could have saved the film. Yes, the book is a generic western, but that doesn’t mean the film has to be. It’s called an adaptation for a reason – it’s not meant to be a copy. A little creativity could have gone a long way in creating what should have been a pretty cool modern western.
