Subjective vs. Objective nature of film discussions. Can film be discussed objectively? I say it can. What say you?
Alright, so I recently read somewhere I can’t remember, an article talking about the objectivity vs. subjectivity when talking about films. Most people think that discussions about film are entirely subjective but what some film critics like Ebert have shown is that there is potential for these discussions to be objective. I suppose, as long as there are clear examples and reasons behind what you’re discussing it can be seen as an objective opinion – it can be seen as a fact. For example, if in reviewing a film you give clear facts and examples behind your reasoning it becomes a well-structured objective piece rather than a subjective, unreasoned opinionated feeling.
Either way you look at it, whether film discussions are subjective or objective, it still remains an opinion and how well you argue it depends on how good that opinion is and what you can say to prop up your argument. Therefore in some instances, there is a right and a wrong answer and that depends on how well you can argue your point with relevant facts and observations. But there will always be people who find something wrong with an objective argument and will use pieces of that argument to make their own subjective opinion against it. To them I say, ‘whatever floats your boat’. Everyone has an opinion, but the important thing is to read and watch critically with an open mind and respect and appreciation for what you are watching, reading or discussing.
So, what do you think about the subjective vs. objective nature of film discussions? Can there be well-reasoned objective arguments for or against a certain film or film movement? Or is the discussion of film completely subjective? What about those who turn subjectivity into negativity to argue how wrong something is? I think this happens all the time, when people fail to respectfully argue against an opinion and it turns into an emotional negative argument against the film or discussion.
What say you? I welcome your comments on this subjective vs. objective nature of film discussions. And don’t nitpick what I say, I’m simply opening up a new discussion on this topic. Please be respectful of other people’s arguments.
